Man of the Year 2011 - John Key

In six elections that I have been eligible to, I am yet to vote for National but I came the closest this year.
What started off as a bland career by a bland suited Banker, has turned into the creation of a necessary populist political phenom.
The term "populist" is a derisory highly insulting one in politics. However as the centre right struggles in an increasingly tepid environment where MMP odds are firmly stacked against it with the potential in buy-a-vote welfare politics by the growing class of net beneficiaries, Key is a stand out.
Union stalwart and Labour insider Mike Williams stated this week the "what if" we (Labour) scored just a couple of percent more list vote.
"What if's" in politics are an hilarious waste of time spoken only of by losers.
Populism isn't a dirty word when you are winning. And every day a Labour MP sits in the House opposite John Key they are reminded of that. They lost because they aren't as popular.
John Key wins my Man of the Year this year as almost singlehandedly he has stopped;
- Capital Gains Tax and with it all Gareth Morgan and Bernard Hickey's bat shit silly ideas
- increasing PAYE rates
- ridiculous GST exemptions
- expansion of Welfare for Families and the welfare state
- most importantly massive blowouts in government expenditure a Labour led coalition would have demanded
- excessive Treaty white guilt payments accompanying a Labour led coalition
- "buy-a-vote" policy from the left
At least for another three years.
Richie McCaw only led consistently the best team in the world to win the RWC on one foot with his fourth choice playmaker. Key's achievements are larger as the stakes are much higher and task more difficult.
National didn't need more of an election strategy than "politics is a team game, everyone shut up so John Key can speak". And he did.
The first time I saw Key's political ability up close was at the surprise party thrown after the botched ACT coup for the outgoing Leader. He did everything more than right that night. Key was magnificent, humble, funny and eloquent. And in all honesty probably had at least half the room list voting National by the end of the night.
Thank God John Key is a populist. The alternative was Don Brash.
He stands solely on principles. He stood this time for 1% of the vote as they weren't principles anyone seemed to connect with.
Principles without political power is a luxury only the richest man can afford. On the right we expect our politicians to have principles and somehow maintain the popularity to have power. We like to think we act purely on principles and criticize each other when we don't act purely. The Libertarianz are the grandest example of this behaviour and 1,405 people voted for them. Power and keeping the left from power are the only important matters.
John Key understands politics, he understands polls, coalitions and MMP. He also understands strategy and knows winning is everything. Thank God for that because very few on the centre-right have worked it out.
Key was already thinking how to cut Don Brash's throat well before the tea tapes. He knew that ACT with Hide was a different partner than ACT with the man he'd already knifed in his career, Don Brash. A wounded man looking now for revenge on Key who started his reign as ACT leader criticizing him. Key had seen Brash's callous disregard for strategy, political nous and cunning as a player in his axing of Hide without bringing the Party with him, or even some outside help to run it. A coup without an army. He'd seen Brash lose an election for National, he'd seen his lack of ability to play the public and incompetence and sloppiness dealing with media and staff. His lack of ability to take advice and play on the team.
If Key was still a banker and he took on a team of employees with Brash in it, the first for the pink slip would be Brash as despite his measurable intellect he was otherwise a liability.
Key knew Brash would cut off his nose to spite his face and attempt to destroy not only Key but the centre-right with it.
I am sure being stuck with co-coup plotter John Banks wasn't Plan A, B or C for Key but it is rumoured that together with Banks he plotted rolling Brash even before the tea tapes. The only matter was the timing.
In the last fortnight of the campaign Key looked almost physically out for the count. Like a banker working 20 hours a day on an international deal for weeks on end. But somehow he hung on and was still doing the business at the National Party function election night at 1am, photos, talking, thanking those who had assisted the Party.
Key's only mistake was his very late endorsement of changing MMP to SM. Even then I have confidence that Key, the politician, will rectify Simon Power's ineptness and come up with something to give him and the National Party a chance at a third term.
So he's in Hawaii? Good job. Having a nice holiday with his family away from New Zealand voters haranguing him. They had long enough to do that on the election campaign.
Key damn well deserves a holiday for saving New Zealand for at least three more years from a Labour let government. His job now is to come back and scheme up a way to keep it all this way past 2014 and with it ensure National and the centre-right do not suffer the same fate Helen Clark and Labour have.

20 Comments:
Still cannot fathom the reason for the one mis-step that brought back Winston (and 7 more of his ilk) to the Parliament--why make those silly comments at the tea party ?
While in sympathy with your views, for me, Key's halo will remain tarnished---unless he can engineer the NZ First party sacking Peters and aligning/merging with the Nats before the end of the year !
I saw and heard Key say on TV somewhere, that in the future, Maori would gain the confidence not to need the Maori seats. This was a 'significant ' statement to me. Never saw it re-reported anywhere. Add that to the list, although it is future gazing.
"Populism' is, of course, an antithesis to the views of, for example, Hayek. I would have thought that you would find Mr Key deeply unsatisfying, as I do, but from a quite different, principled position. One does not have to be the disaster that is Dr Brash to be principled. Of course, the art of populism is to subvert principle and bring people to the image and insubstantial as moths to a flame......
John Key does not qualify - is a splitarse.
I find it concerning that populist is better grasped than principles. That indicates a fair wack of the country appear too stupid to be trusted with the vote. Maybe that's the left's moral high ground - a fair wack of their supposed supporters don't vote if it requires effort - so they do the right thing but out of laziness.
I still think Key is not the answer - he's a product of economic policy that increasingly is looking like a failure - and we are yet to see the collapse.
Cactus Kate
I read your blog to my husband and the warmth surged over me.
You are so astute.
Thank God for John Key
You are so right .
He saved N.Z. from the dumb left partys.
The Otago Daily Times have started their anti Key already in todays publication.
JoanJ
Nice one CK. Nailed it beautifully!
Haven't you been hypnotised?
What use is power for the right when they have been converted into neo-leftists? Failure to stand on a principled foundation results in disasters like ACT became...no thanks...that strategy has failed.
I'm pleased thatTeflonic. Stealthy assassin. Steady. Objective. Calculated. Compare Key campaigns, 2008 to Key 2011. The man has grown into overall a quietly effective politician in my opinion. Key knows he needs at least 3 terms in total to fulfill his agenda. So he will still tread lightly for this term, but I have to tell all you anti-Key people out there. I think you underestimate this man and I think he's just hitting his stride. I think the man is capable of 3 terms, no doubt. Four is possible. He could be around for a long time.
Yes, you are right. Key will be remembered as popular, but he won't be remembered as a leader that had depth. The Key era will be remembered as a strange time when NZers traded what was good for NZ for feeling good listening to Key, regardless of what he said.
Very good post. I think it has been easy to underestimate JK, and he has thoroughly unnerved the Labour party. i suspect the main reason is because they cannot understand him as none of them have every really had proper jobs before.
From my observation, Key was triumphant over one of the most biased, appallingly reported elections in living memory where the 24 yo know it all journos did everything possible to sabotage his campaign.
No mean feat I would have thought.
Lee Kuan Yew in his latest book says that "All great leaders need to be feared and loved, if I had to choose between the two I would rather be feared"
Key has got the Love nailed now I would like to see him using some fear as a tool as well to get thing done.
Well written piece as usual!
Anon @6:58, yup, Nat bank rollers have said that too, cant understand the sheer stupidity behind the teacups mis-handling. (Hooton?)
He has one more term to deliver measurable results or he is out.
Key has stopped nothing. By time the subnormal get back into power they will have added another dozen ways to tax the productive and enlarge the welfare state.
He couldn’t win an ideological argument to save himself or NZ. Key the ultimate care taker prime minister.
He's also the winner of the cross species Reptilian Shapeshifter of the year - 2011
double congrats !!!
Cathy, I have never voted National in my life and last election would never have been an exception under any circumstances, especially with John Key as PM.
I give him credit for the tough job he has to perform as PM and he has had a GFC, mine and earthquake disaster or two to contend with as well.
But for me Key is merely managing the country, there is no bold vision, nor is there any willingness to reverse the UN doctrine we got under Clark.
Key is on record as saying he will lead a moderate centrist govt and that is what we have had since 2008but we need reform.
Steady as she goes doesnt cut it any longer, we need real transformation in education, welfare, health and superannuation (as a transformation al package).
Kevin Campbell
KC
That's all fine but even getting 15% in MMP doesn't ensure that transformation.
Labour with Mana and greenswill transform everything you have posted sure enough, just not in the way you want.
That's your choice.
Key is a very able 'frontman'...much like Obama in the U.S.A....has similar donors/puppeteers too...don't forget to bring back knighthoods Johnny..Doug is a big patron and hes miffed that he missed out ,while Humpty and Bob got their payoff years ago.
Only 15%? Long-term we need to be much more ambitious than that.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home